Thursday, September 9, 2010

Illmatic vs. Paid in Full - An Objective Review

For centuries, hip-hop enthusiasts have debated which was the best hip-hop album of all time. Old school cats spoke highly of Eric B. & Rakim's 1987 masterpiece, Paid in Full. Those of a slightly later era took up the flag for Nas' 1994 epic, Illmatic. Morons and Pitchfork Media dipshits probably voted for 808s and Heartbreak or the Blueprint III. Anyways, to settle the issue once and for all I present an objective, track-by-track comparison of Illmatic and Paid in Full.

1. I Ain't No Joke-Eric B. and Rakim
This song starts with what sounds like the beat from one of those Bop-It toys. Rakim states, "I'm no comedian," over horns that sound like the intro to a Dean Martin roast. Rakim asks a question as serious as cancer, something about keeping a dancer hyped or some shit. Eric B. has some extended scratching solo, which is fine for track 1 but could get annoying. He says something about a "punchline," which is odd because three minutes ago he said he wasn't a comedian. I'm not really sure what the fuck this song is about. Apparently, they ain't no joke. Which is clear from the hockey jersey and beret get-up on the album cover.

1. The Genesis-Nas
The album starts with what I can only assume is a clip from some Scarface rip-off movie. "Hey, yo Nas, let's count this money." This is fucking terrible...somebody just said something about "grab-ass" I think. At 1:45, I'm not sure if this is a track or a sketch..."Take this Hennessey man"...this song should be called, "Lazy racial stereotypes as filler." Also, the kid on the album cover has been played out...though I guess Nas was the first to do it so he gets a pass. Apparently, this is an intro to "Illmatic," as the end of the track says, but if the rest of the album is this painfully stupid, I can understand why Jay-Z wanted to pummel his ass.

ADVANTAGE: Eric B. and Rakim, hands down

2.NY State of Mind-Nas
"Straight out the fuckin' dungeons of rap..."thanks John Jamelske. This beat and bass sounds like something over which Cypress Hill should be rapping about smoking weed and cutting people's faces off or whatever the hell they rapped about when they were relevant 20 years ago...that is to say, I like it. This seems to be a social commentary on young African-Americans becoming involved in gang life. "I know this crackhead who likes to smoke nice, right." Yeah, those crackheads are always picky. They're always looking for a nice chianti. Alright, I'm a white guy from Eden, NY, I got no idea what the fuck this guy is rapping about, but it sounds good. "My rhyming is a vitamin..." Okay, that's just fucking stupid. I didn't think Nas would rival "fish...which is my favorite dish" by Rakim as dumbest line in this match-up. This song is infinitely better than Empire State of Mind...which sucks and makes me like this song even more.

2. Eric B. is on the Cut-Eric B. and Rakim
Alright this scratching shit is starting to get really fucking annoying, like some of that lame-ass non-threatening white boy late 90s Beastie Boys shit. Although this does sort of sound like what people in 1987 would have thought music would sound like in 1998. I thought Rakim was a great rapper? It's a fucking minute and a half into this piece of shit and all I've heard is, "Eric B. is on the cut" 45 times. If I had this on vinyl I'd think it was busted. It would appear this song probably inspired 20 years of shitty Beastie Boys records. And for that alone, they should be condemned. As far as lyrical content, it's clear Eric B. is on the cut. I really wish he wasn't. He kind of sucks. This song's got about a minute to redeem itself. It doesn't.

ADVANTAGE: Nas, in what could be considered close to a knockout blow. I seriously doubt anybody not named Vanilla Ice could rival its shittiness.

3. My Melody-Eric B. and Rakim
This song is close to seven minutes long. What the fuck? A whistled intro that sounds like possibly something sampled from Mr. Rogers. And...more terrible scratching. Rakim just compared himself to a scientist, which is unintentionally hilarious as it recalls Kenny Powers. I'm checking out his melody...and it's atrocious. "Any MC that disagree with me wave ya arm..." I understand it was 1987...but is that threatening. Seriously guys, seven minutes? November Rain was only like 8 or 9 and that had a fucking orchestra. This Rakim guy is smooth though. "I can swing off anything even a swing of the heart." Okay, Peter Gabriel would be embarrassed to sing that shit. This music is impressive in the same way the Black Eyed Peas music is impressive...it's not. But it would be twenty years ago...maybe. Which makes it impossible to judge this crap. I thought these guys were supposed to be good. Rakim's got a slightly more impressive flow than anybody from Sugarhill Gang...but none of the hilarious shit like, "I like hot butter on my breakfast toast." Seriously, how long is this piece of crap? And just when I was getting really annoyed...more scratching. This shit goes down smooth in the same way a vanilla milkshake goes down smooth. It's pretty good background noise for a Black Panthers meeting, I suppose, but I doubt you'd remember any of it afterwards. I'm pretty tired of checking out this guys melody. Actually, the whistle and beat at the end is pretty sick...enough to redeem this pile of garbage...?

3. Life's a Bitch-Nas
This song title is terrible...somebody's talking about counting money again. Some girl once wrote in my yearbook, "Life's a bitch and then you die," which for some reason makes me hate this song. The beat sounds like it was borrowed from Boys II Men. Seriously, I can almost hear "One Fine Day," over this crap. Oh, here we go, "Life's a bitch and then you die...that's why we get high..." great logic. He's got rhymes 365 days plus some...that'll lose him some points on the math section. "that buck that bought a bottle coulda struck the lotto." Honestly, the bottle was probably a better investment. Lottery tickets are fucking useless. Plus dumb fucks buying lotto tickets always held me up when I was living in Jersey City trying to buy a copy of the Post on the way to work. I didn't think anything could be worse than My Melody, but damn.

ADVANTAGE: Eric B. and Rakim. Yeah, they're song sucks, but if you talk about buying lottery tickets, you're not a socially conscious rapper, you're a moron.

4. The World is Yours-Nas
A little bit of an Arrested Development vibe on this. This World is Yours shit is getting repetitive. Who do you think you are, Rakim? If I hear this asshole talk about getting money one more fucking time, I'm quitting. Queens shout out. Oh crap, I think he just compared housing police to Hitler. Okay, Nas, you're a fucking idiot. If Glenn Beck is an idiot, you're an idiot. And if there's one thing this song didn't need, it's the type of ass-trocious turntable breakdown I thought I left behind with Eric B. and Rakim. Alright, something about stabbing women. Nice! I like the theme of this song. The world is yours but only if you stab some women and avoid those damn Nazis in the NYC department of housing. Alright, fuck this. I don't need you to go through every single part of the tri-state area. Westchester County...the world is yours. Well, that might make sense. This song is terrible.

4. I Know You Got Soul-Eric B. and Rakim
Alright, I'm not gonna hold it against these guys that the intro was copied in an Aaliyah song...and I think a Marky Mark song. The riff in this song sounds like Kurt Cobain during Unplugged in New York covering a Parliament Funkadelic song...that is to say, I like it. It'd be nice if Rakim rapped about anything other than the act of rapping itself. He compared himself to a scientist again though. I like it. Seriously, this guy's like that kid in a creative writing class who writes about writing. He's like Natasha Bedingfield in These Words or Unwritten. Alright, we know you're on the mic. Now do something. A crowd starts chanting "You got it!" This is like the soundtrack to a Spike Lee movie. Sorry...a Spike Lee joint. Some disturbing turntable work that sounds like a man being raped. Rakim wants to see who can dance the best. This is like the rap version of Solid Gold: it's cheesy as hell and it's apparently about who can dance the best to some crappy beat for six minutes straight.

ADVANTAGE: Eric B. and Rakim. If you mention Hitler, you lose. Unless it's like a historical song. "Hitler, 1942, tell me what's a brother to do?"

5. Move the Crowd-Eric B. and Rakim.
So far it seems like Nas only wants to rap about having money, getting money, and Adolf Hitler. And Rakim just wants to see who can dance the best. Which makes me think Nas is a bit selfish, but Rakim is just fucking stupid. Yes! Eric B. and Rakim made a video for this piece of shit! We got a synth riff that sounds like it's played by Tom Hanks on that big keyboard in the movie Big. Alright, in the video, Rakim is dressed as a military leader trying to lead his troops to make the people move. Now he's a preacher, now a politician...same mission, obviously. This song sucks. But the video has a high level of unintentional hilarity. Nothing says I'm making a serious political statement but I'm still a dumbass like a guy wearing combat fatigues and six chains around his neck. It's like Mr. T joined the National Guard. Rakim just, to paraphrase, told everybody to shut up while he's got the mic. What are you, a substitute teacher. "All praises due to Allah." Now that's some controversial shit. Of course, twenty years ago, not only did white people not know who Allah is, they weren't listening to Rakim. And honestly, I can see why. The "crowd" is wearing Detroit Lions jackets. What kind of alternative universe is this?

5. Halftime-Nas
At least Nas has the decency to inform me this garbage is halfway over. Assuming I couldn't count halfway from ten. And I thought counting was a central theme? Oh, this is nice. Thumping bass drum and a moving bass line is enough to get any suburban white asshole dancing. Nas about to cause mass hysteria. And...surprise...he's talking about weed. And he just analogized something or other about weed to Malcolm X. Once again, just to be clear. Name dropping Malcolm X. when the rest of the song is about how good a rapper you are and how much weed you smoke does not make you socially conscious; it makes you a pandering douchebag. He's "as ill as a convict that kills for fun time?" Yes, more kicks than something about a baby's stomach. He's got a lot of shoes. Wow, this is some deep shit. "I rap in front of more n----- than on a slave ship." And, he just used the word faggot. These lyrics are fucking inane. I do appreciate the fact that they appear to be celebrating the fact that this crap is halfway over. "I won't plant seeds don't need an extra mouth I can't feed." Practice safe sex? This thing reads like an after school special. Unless you're a faggot of course. And stop name-dropping every borough. Who do you think you are, Jay-Z.

ADVANTAGE: Nas. His lyrics are terrible, but the beat is insane. And I'm tired of Rakim rapping about dancing.

6. Memory Lane-Nas
"Fuck that other shit." Great intro. You probably didn't have to record the argument you had with the producer. And did he just call himself the Grand Wizard. Retardedly? Excellent, I was checking that off of the "offensive words I wanted you to drop for no reason" category. Can we get a cunt please? This piano tinkling sounds like something from an alternate take of Free Bird. "My medicine is my ganja." I understand this is supposed to be social commentary, but is this guy's reaction to everything to get massively high? He pours out a Heineken to his deceased crew? What is this guy, a fucking South Shore guido? Queensbridge is mentioned heavily, which I appreciate. Because Ron Artest is from Queensbridge.

6. Paid in Full-Eric B. and Rakim
This one is the classic. The song starts with what appears to be Eric B. and Rakim discussing their current management situation. Once again fellas, the arguments don't have to be included on the album. This song samples the same bass line from "Don't Look Any Further," which is also used in Hit 'Em Up, which is a better song that any track on either of these atrocities. I guess this song is about Rakim looking for a job. Oh, now they're talking about making up with their girlfriends 'cause they took too long to make this record. I couldn't tell. And girlfriends? What the fuck is this? Pinkerton?

ADVANTAGE: Eric B. and Rakim. Grab ya glocks when ya see 2Pac...

7. As the Rhyme Goes On-Eric B. and Rakim
Pump it up, homeboy! Slow start on this one, it's like Glycerine by Bush if Bush was a mid-80s rap duo. His rhymes are oxygen. The type of suffocating oxygen that beats you over the head. Rakim just said "I'm the R to tha A to the K-I-M." It's the rhythm Eminem uses on "I Am." Just for that, they lose a shit load of points. And did I just hear a Beastie Boy? I hope not. I did. They lose.

7. One Love-Nas
It starts with what sound like guys hustling on the streets. Nas is explaining to some kid that he should have hid out at his place when the cops came. Oh no, and somebody got shot on the way home from Jones Beach. It was 1994, I can only assume they were at a Counting Crows show. This song wasn't bad until this aggravating One Love crap started. This thing's got like a weird marimba solo in the background. It's like a xylophone riff played by Meg White. I kinda like it. Except for this annoying One Love shit, the song isn't bad. He just instructed a kid that the guy who gets shot to death loses. Very important.

ADVANTAGE: Nas. Did you miss the part about Rakim inspiring Eminem?

8. One Time for Your Mind-Nas
Stop telling me it's Illmatic, I don't know what the fuck that means. He likes to chill, drink beers and watch movies. This guy is a fucking American original. It's a night for sexin'. And I can think of no better love making music than this, with it's meandering bassline and off kilter off key guitar chord interruptions. It's like the intro to Here Comes Your Man by Pixies, only played intermittently throughout this song. Police wanna murder him. And surprise, he's talking about smoking weed again. Weed does make you paranoid, doesn't it? He holds a Mac 11, and attacks a Reverend. From 92 to 99? Why the hell is he still making records in 2010?

8. Chinese Arithmetic-Eric B. & Rakim
This has all the makings of an hilarious novelty song. It starts with that Turning Japanese "da da da da da da duh duh da" thing. And now Eric B. is scratching over it. Please don't let him start saying he's on the cut. If Rakim is such a great lyricist, how come this is the second track out of ten he doesn't even appear on? Eric B. appears to have sampled such innovative sounds as a glass of water being poured. I thought at the very least we'd get some hilarious racial stereotypes in this song. As much as I make fun of Nas for being high, it's clear these guys must have been high as shit to think "let's take that Oriental Riff from bad kung fu movies and scratch it up for five minutes."

ADVANTAGE: Nas. One Time for Your Mind is a competently produced, if highly annoying rap song. Chinese Arithmetic has all the hallmarks of something Phineas Gage would have made, given the resources, in 1855.

9. Eric B. is President-Eric B. & Rakim
This song is going to suck. Eric B., the guy who has wasted 14 minutes of my life on one listen of this record with his pointless turntable noodling, wants to be president? Well, I suppose we elected George Bush and his old man. Okay, this song seems to be sampling 1980s infomercials. "B-b-b-b-buy a Ronco juicer." "I came in the door, I said it before..." This rhyme was copied by the late Rich from LFO in their hit "Summer Girls." That song is fucking hilarious. Mostly because the guy...wait, hold on, Eric B. is on the cut again. Anyways, LFO's lead singer called William Shakespeare "Billy Shakespeare." I like that. I call Michael J. Fox, Mike Fox, and so on. Rakim is bitching about some girl who said she hated him. Once again, what is this, the hip-hop Pinkerton? Ohhh, pink triangle...Eric B. is on the cut! "Make 'em clap to this!" Make a song other than a laughably terrible farse. Drop your hip, drop your hip...this is like some Chubby Checker dance instruction bullshit. This one ends with what sounds like Eric B. starting up a chainsaw...we can only hope.

9. Represent-Nas
Nas has an annoying habit of starting every song with a bunch of guys fucking talking to each other. I know he's from Queensbridge, but did he have to record this shit on a Queensbridge sidewalk? Seriously, how the fuck is this social commentary? All he talks about is drinking, smoking, and killing people. Even Ludacris inserted a "this shit's gotta stop" from time to time. "Life ain't shit but stress." If Paid in Full is the hip hop Pinkerton, this is the hip hop equivalent of some 14 year old emo girl's MySpace page. On the plus side, the production on this track is great. It sounds a bit like "Insane in the Brain." Once again, One Time for Your Mind...and more shoutouts. Seriously, did this guy accidentally make a critically acclaimed hip hop album while simply trying to say hello to his fucking friends? "Come to Queensbridge, motherfucker!" Well, you've certainly inticed me with this album.

ADVANTAGE: Eric B. and Rakim. They influenced Summer Girls, one of the most hilarious novelty songs of all time. RIP Rich Cronin.

10. It Ain't Hard to Tell-Nas
This is the one Nas blew up with. At least, according to the guy who posted the video to YouTube. In the video, he's got an hilarious 1994 cell phone. He's got a sniper's breath, which I can only assume smells like army rations and despair. Did he just reference Aesop, of Aesop's fables? And Shaquille? "I leave your brain stimulated." Uh, no, you haven't. By the way, how cold was the NYC winter in 1994? Nas is dressed like he's in fucking Siberia.

10. Extended Beat-Eric B. and Rakim
This extended beat sounds like it was created on a TR 808. Samples of crowds cheering. How desperate for approval are you no talent fucks? Guitar noodling sounds like it was done by a young Bernie Williams. This is called Extended Beat, but it's not nearly as long as those shitty scratching songs. And, for the record, no Rakim. So the challenger to the throne of greatest rapper alive at the time didn't bother to show up on nearly a third of these tracks.

ADVANTAGE: Nas. I'm tired of Rakim not rapping. Plus Nas referenced Aesop.

WINNER: Well, it's a 5-5 tie. But Eric B. and Rakim annoyed the shit out of me. Nas had the better record, but if either one of these is the best of all time, we got a major fucking problem.